skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Amazing pizza and fair price ... read more
Het Thakkar via google.com - May 22, 2022
Delicious pizza and garlic knots for a reasonable price! They have a nice seating area as well Defin
Delicious pizza and garlic knots for a reasonable price! They have a nice seating area as well Definitely recommend!
Sakura F. via yelp.com - May 22, 2022
At least in my experience, It was a cozy environment with friendly faces and great customer service.
At least in my experience, It was a cozy environment with friendly faces and great customer service. Also not to mention they have one of the best pizzas I've ever tried!
Angel J. via yelp.com - May 22, 2022
Made In New York what can I say about it. Looking for a New York on upper west side look no more Mad
Made In New York what can I say about it. Looking for a New York on upper west side look no more Made in New York the spot.
Jirayut C. via yelp.com - May 21, 2022
Gas!!!! The pizza here was so good, it literally made my night feel so much more full.
Gas!!!! The pizza here was so good, it literally made my night feel so much more full.
Aidan S. via yelp.com - May 21, 2022
Love the spicy pepperoni slice. Try it with honey for a sweet and salty hit ... read more
Juan Restrepo via google.com - May 20, 2022
Great Pizza!!!
GIAN via google.com - May 19, 2022
Great pizza!
Ben Fiedler via google.com - May 19, 2022
We've been looking for our favorite pizza delivery on the UWS and have found it in Made in New York
We've been looking for our favorite pizza delivery on the UWS and have found it in Made in New York Pizza. We ordered the spicy pepperoni and vodka sauce pizzas. Both were delicious; however, I'll say that the spicy pepperoni was a little too much for me (very dense, just sat in my stomach afterwards). Order and enjoy!
Jennifer S. via yelp.com - May 19, 2022
Love the pizza! Great selection, Long hours and friendly staff. They also have a beer selection
Love the pizza! Great selection, Long hours and friendly staff. They also have a beer selection ... read more
Ben F. via yelp.com - May 19, 2022
Amazing and affordable!
Terena Bell via google.com - May 18, 2022
Great food and pizza. I love the ambience in here. It's like I stepped into a New York pizza joint
Great food and pizza. I love the ambience in here. It's like I stepped into a New York pizza joint ... read more
Mark B. via yelp.com - May 18, 2022
Really good pizza! Truly the taste of new York! GOOD STUFFFFFF! Yum yum yum yum yum yum!
Really good pizza! Truly the taste of new York! GOOD STUFFFFFF! Yum yum yum yum yum yum!
Andrew W. via yelp.com - May 18, 2022
The best pizza! Seriously.
Kirsten McCann via google.com - May 16, 2022
This was the first pizza we had during our trip to NY. After looking through the reviews, we decided
This was the first pizza we had during our trip to NY. After looking through the reviews, we decided to get a slice (square) of the white and spicy pepperoni. | Spicy Pepperoni - 4.75 Square pizza with spicy pepperoni's. I love how the pepperoni's curl up and form little cups when they're baked. They are quite oily though, like legit ... read more
Jannell L. via yelp.com - May 16, 2022
Good pizza ... read more
peter dihayco via google.com - May 15, 2022
Good pizza would recommend to a friend ... read more
bill li via google.com - May 15, 2022
I really loved the customer service and the cleanliness of the store! It wasn't hard to find a table
I really loved the customer service and the cleanliness of the store! It wasn't hard to find a table and the lines were next to nothing! Loved it ... read more
Aman S. via yelp.com - May 15, 2022
I really like the pizzas here! The restaurant itself looks really good. You don't have to wait all t
I really like the pizzas here! The restaurant itself looks really good. You don't have to wait all that long for your food to come!
Rain C. via yelp.com - May 15, 2022
Great pizza!
cara susskind via google.com - May 14, 2022
Great place in a few minutes from central park, delicious pizza for every taste and preference , time of waiting is pretty fast, just order it and in a few minutes enjoy your choice ... read more
Мария Чуперка via google.com - May 14, 2022
Best pizza ever! It's so great and fresh! I love pizza!! This place deserves a medal. It's so delici
Best pizza ever! It's so great and fresh! I love pizza!! This place deserves a medal. It's so delicious and everyone should come!
Hayley F. via yelp.com - May 14, 2022
Highly recommend this pizza place, multiple different varieties of pizza! Classic NY pizza!
Highly recommend this pizza place, multiple different varieties of pizza! Classic NY pizza!
Edgar M. via yelp.com - May 14, 2022
7/10 pizza, 8.5/10 garlic knots 10/10 Marinara sauce ... read more
Mortem via google.com - May 13, 2022
BEST PIZZA EVER ... read more
Juliet Kelter via google.com - May 13, 2022
Great pizza!!! Always quick and easy. Reasonable priced for what you're getting !!!!$
Great pizza!!! Always quick and easy. Reasonable priced for what you're getting !!!!$ ... read more
Kate R. via yelp.com - May 12, 2022
Great authentic New York Pizza place. Very clean interior and quick service. Couldn't wish for any more!
Crimson Legacy via google.com - May 10, 2022
Fantastic pizza and great service!
Ashton Loosli via google.com - May 10, 2022
The Pizza Is Good great service
The Pizza Is Good great service ... read more
Alison N. via yelp.com - May 9, 2022
Tasty variety here. I enjoyed both sliced. The eggplant looked and did taste so good. Tons of marina
Tasty variety here. I enjoyed both sliced. The eggplant looked and did taste so good. Tons of marinara. The eggplant was surprisingly good too, usually don't care for those. The crest is yummy. The pepperoni mushroom was a loooong piece and really good. They heat it up right before handing to you. Nice seating inside. Efficient line ... read more
Cole D. via yelp.com - May 7, 2022
Amazing food 🇮🇹🇮🇹🤌🤌🔥🔥 ... read more
Max Dashefsky via google.com - May 6, 2022
DELICIOUS ... read more
Charlie Coco puff via google.com - May 5, 2022
Awesome pizza ... read more
Stephen via google.com - May 5, 2022
Old school NY slices! I had an eggplant, mozz, Scillian slice. It was incredible! Definitely hit this up if you’re on the UWS.
Jason Braunstein via google.com - May 5, 2022
Best pizza on UWS! Tasty and fresh slices with good ingredients. Fast service which is always a plus
Best pizza on UWS! Tasty and fresh slices with good ingredients. Fast service which is always a plus when looking for a quick bite.
Terry L. via yelp.com - May 5, 2022
Tasty slices at a reasonable price. I had a fresh mozzarella with eggplant. Nice variety of slices.
Tasty slices at a reasonable price. I had a fresh mozzarella with eggplant. Nice variety of slices.
Ken R. via yelp.com - May 5, 2022
Super good NY style pizzas, actually the best I had for now ! I recommend the square pepperoni ... read more
Maël Mountassir via google.com - May 4, 2022
In New York we make the best pizza ... read more
Kiyaan Moorman via google.com - May 3, 2022
Delicious pizza! Got the last slice of spinach and mushroom. Lucky me. We walked over 2 miles to get
Delicious pizza! Got the last slice of spinach and mushroom. Lucky me. We walked over 2 miles to get here and it was definitely worth it ... read more
Laurie D. via yelp.com - May 3, 2022
I usually get the spicy pepperoni, to me it's one of the more flavorful choices they have, it's load
I usually get the spicy pepperoni, to me it's one of the more flavorful choices they have, it's loaded with spicy cups, and if you get a pie they really load it up with the pepperoni. I like their grandma slice as well, some of the other square slices are kinda too saucy, touch more cheese would help balance out the ratio to the slig ... read more
Tanya W. via yelp.com - May 2, 2022
Great place and the pizza tastes good.. very recommended..
Jaime Nyu via google.com - May 1, 2022
As a person living in LA, it isn't common that I like pizza, but this is delicious! They have so many to choose from and it's always very fresh ... read more
Yelyzaveta Nechay via google.com - May 1, 2022
Epic pizza ... read more
Bryan Krosser via google.com - Apr 24, 2022
Very good !
William Dalton via google.com - Apr 24, 2022
Amazing slice!
Connor Crandall via google.com - Apr 23, 2022
Best Eggplant Parm!
Nam Phu via google.com - Apr 22, 2022
Best pizza in NYC! :) ... read more
Ash H via google.com - Apr 22, 2022
The best service, fresh pizza and great late night environment! Thankful for the staff! 10/10 recommend! 🍕 ... read more
Chloe Riven via google.com - Apr 22, 2022
I'm from NY (living in NJ currently) and obviously NY pizza is the best. My boyfriend is from NJ and he's never had NY pizza until today. I took him here and he enjoyed it a lot. He said it's the best pizza he's ever had. Next time I'm back in the city, I will definitely be coming back ... read more
Emma Tulotta via google.com - Apr 21, 2022
Świetne miejsce na szybką pizzę. Można kupić kawałek i zjeść na miejscu albo wziąć na wynos. Duży wybór. Polecam!
Kamil Brzeziński via google.com - Apr 21, 2022
Amazing! great pizza with great customer service. I defintely recommend getting the pepporoni square
Amazing! great pizza with great customer service. I defintely recommend getting the pepporoni square!
Hayden S. via yelp.com - Apr 20, 2022
This is my favorite pizza joint on the UWS. Vodka slice is especially good but everything I've tried
This is my favorite pizza joint on the UWS. Vodka slice is especially good but everything I've tried has been great here. Just really high quality NY pizza.
Jack M. via yelp.com - Apr 20, 2022
I was looking for a New York Slice, and that's exactly what I got here! It wasn't the best pizza in the world of course, but it was exactly what I was looking for.
Austin Fan via google.com - Apr 16, 2022
This is the best pizza we’ve tried in NYC! The BBQ Chicken was delicious.
D Car via google.com - Apr 15, 2022
good place to go after a night out!!!! barbeque chicken slice is very good. definitely recommend
good place to go after a night out!!!! barbeque chicken slice is very good. definitely recommend ... read more
Jason L. via yelp.com - Apr 15, 2022
Come to the Big Apple - NEED to have my favorite pizza 💪🏻❤️🍎 🍕🇺🇸 ... read more
Paul Schott via google.com - Apr 13, 2022
A review is a review, a pizza slice is a pizza slice. When I saw somebody stopped in and gave it pra
A review is a review, a pizza slice is a pizza slice. When I saw somebody stopped in and gave it praise, I had to stop at this Upper West Side pizza shop and compare. For this review I ate five slices. For you judgmental folk, I had absolutely no lunch today, this makes up for that. Forgive me for being a pig for eating a lot of pizz ... read more
Matthew S. via yelp.com - Apr 13, 2022
My go-to uws pizza stop. I find myself here at all hours of the day. When they reheat slices they ar
My go-to uws pizza stop. I find myself here at all hours of the day. When they reheat slices they are perfectly crunchy on the bottom. I usually get a mushroom slice but their granny square with pepperoni is great too ... read more
Katie S. via yelp.com - Apr 13, 2022
TOTALLY RECOMMEND! Check it out! The smell alone will draw you in!
William Rivera via google.com - Apr 12, 2022
Friendly staff and very quick. Get the spicy pepperoni. Definitely the best pizza I've had on the UW
Friendly staff and very quick. Get the spicy pepperoni. Definitely the best pizza I've had on the UWS.
Drew L. via yelp.com - Apr 12, 2022
The pizza here is very good. The square grandmas slice with pepperoni is simply excellent. The crust
The pizza here is very good. The square grandmas slice with pepperoni is simply excellent. The crust is the best part. They also have an eggplant parmesan that is wonderful if you're not in the mood for pizza. Many eggplant parmesan dishes are heavy or greasy, but this one was really wonderful. Recommended.
Thomas C. via yelp.com - Apr 12, 2022
Best slice on the UWS ... read more
Lauren Glassman via google.com - Apr 11, 2022
I do really like this pizza, especially due to their fresh ingredients, but in general I find their
I do really like this pizza, especially due to their fresh ingredients, but in general I find their dough to be salty. It's still delicious!
Heather W. via yelp.com - Apr 11, 2022
Very good pizza ... read more
Proscoobysnack ! via google.com - Apr 10, 2022
Wonderful! New York Cheese Cake. 🧀 ... read more
Kanokwan Anusak via google.com - Apr 10, 2022
This place absolutely slaps. I got the Detroit style pizza and it was phenomenal. I'll definitely be
This place absolutely slaps. I got the Detroit style pizza and it was phenomenal. I'll definitely be going here again next time I'm in the area.
Nick C. via yelp.com - Apr 10, 2022
This is truly a great pizza spot I originally wrote the 5 star for the slice but this pizza is actually the best I’ve had so far in New York, different type of sauce that gives the pizza a unique and beautiful taste plus comes crispy and hot ... read more
Lado Ramishvili via google.com - Apr 9, 2022
Great pizza! Best in the city. I always come when I'm visiting New York. Must visit again soon
Great pizza! Best in the city. I always come when I'm visiting New York. Must visit again soon ... read more
Terry L. via yelp.com - Apr 9, 2022
Some of the best pizza in upper west side! Super crispy and good fresh ingredients if you need a qui
Some of the best pizza in upper west side! Super crispy and good fresh ingredients if you need a quick slice go here!
Bristol B. via yelp.com - Apr 9, 2022
My favorite pizza spot. I love it here. Will always be my favorite place for a slice at all times.
My favorite pizza spot. I love it here. Will always be my favorite place for a slice at all times.
Sanford W. via yelp.com - Apr 8, 2022
Excellent slices! One of the UWS's finest!
Eli Robinson via google.com - Apr 7, 2022
Great pizza ... read more
arda cam via google.com - Apr 6, 2022
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire