skip to main content skip to footer

Reviews

Pizza was great. They offered gluten free which is a plus for me when I have celiac. They even put my own pizza cutter in the box to keep from cross contamination. Loved this place.
Melissa Mathis via google.com - Sep 19, 2021
Great pizza, great selection, and great prices. Did I mention, great pizza. By far, it it is the bes
Great pizza, great selection, and great prices. Did I mention, great pizza. By far, it it is the best to go pizza on the upper west side.
Average C. via yelp.com - Sep 18, 2021
Wow ... read more
Leon Stevens via google.com - Sep 16, 2021
One of the best New York styles pizzas in the upper west side ... read more
Amish Shah via google.com - Sep 12, 2021
Perfect crust, perfect sauce, perfect pepperoni cups! Loved the square pepperoni pizza slice we enjo
Perfect crust, perfect sauce, perfect pepperoni cups! Loved the square pepperoni pizza slice we enjoyed. A great stop on the Upper West Side. One of the culinary highlights of our trip to NY only set us back $13 for 2 slices and a bottled water!
Stacy G. via yelp.com - Sep 10, 2021
Vodka slice was the reason we initially came here. That did not disappoint, but what really surprise
Vodka slice was the reason we initially came here. That did not disappoint, but what really surprised me was a white square slice they had (it was on thick Sicilian bread). Wow, it is not just white cheeses. It's also garlic and oh my was I pleasantly surprised. I could eat that pizza everyday and be VERY happy... very unhealthy but ... read more
Dana M. via yelp.com - Sep 7, 2021
Best pizza in uws for sure. Margarita is amazing, upside down spot on, and mushroom is very shroomy.
Best pizza in uws for sure. Margarita is amazing, upside down spot on, and mushroom is very shroomy. I wish the operations was smoother, but can't blame them for being busy ... read more
Ethan H. via yelp.com - Sep 6, 2021
Unfortunately my visit here was later in the evening after being rushed out of the VIP ticket sectio
Unfortunately my visit here was later in the evening after being rushed out of the VIP ticket section before the final two hours of the I NYC Homecoming Concert. So Depressing. My daughter lives by the park, so after the final cancellation announcement on CNN, we donned rain gear and braved torrential rains the two blocks it took to ... read more
Cathy O. via yelp.com - Sep 3, 2021
Im always looking for good pizza. Not much to be found in California. I was in NYC to drop daughter
Im always looking for good pizza. Not much to be found in California. I was in NYC to drop daughter of at college and was on a search for great pizza. Found Made in Mew York and it did not let me down. Fold it pizza. Thin crunchy crust. Pepperoni for me. It was excellent. I shall return!!
Brad M. via yelp.com - Aug 31, 2021
Get some slices ... read more
Tyler Scott via google.com - Aug 30, 2021
great pizza. good location, pepperoni cups are great. cheap prices. tastes goood!!!!!!'nnnnnnnnnnn
great pizza. good location, pepperoni cups are great. cheap prices. tastes goood!!!!!!'nnnnnnnnnnn ... read more
D L. via yelp.com - Aug 30, 2021
Cozy spot w great slices. Loved it, will be back again ... read more
Munsif Husami via google.com - Aug 29, 2021
Delicious and friendly.
Kathryn Medland via google.com - Aug 29, 2021
Great pizza joint with great customer service. Been wanting to eat here for ages and finally flew from Australia to NYC and tried it. Worth giving a try if you’re in uptown Manhattan ... read more
George Riad via google.com - Aug 28, 2021
Our go to pizza place on the UWS .
Alec Francis via google.com - Aug 28, 2021
Great pizza by the slice!! Was in and out in 10 minutes. I had the pepperoni and sausage and a slice of the Margherita. Both were delish. Their garlic knots are also dope. Slices are huge. I ate 1.5 and ate the rest the next day.
Jessi Scott via google.com - Aug 22, 2021
4.5 / 5.0 - Either I was really hungry or the pizza was really good--or it was a combination of both
4.5 / 5.0 - Either I was really hungry or the pizza was really good--or it was a combination of both. I had the Fresh Mozzarella Margherita Pizza Slice ($4.50+), which was a delicious combination of the fresh mozzarella cheese, tomato sauce and basil. The crust was a little too soft for a NY pizza, but I thoroughly enjoyed my slice a ... read more
Sawako Y. via yelp.com - Aug 20, 2021
The pizza here was delicious!!!. Vodka, Margarita and spicy pepperoni is what I got..😋 and so was the garlic knots!
Jon B via google.com - Aug 13, 2021
I have been searching for a pizza spot in the UWS and this might be it. I had the classic spicy pepp
I have been searching for a pizza spot in the UWS and this might be it. I had the classic spicy pepperoni and the cheese pizza. I must say the cheese pizza took me by surprise and I liked that over the spicy pepperoni square. I will definitely re-try this spot but it is delicious!
Lucy C. via yelp.com - Aug 11, 2021
Typical take out/dine in pizza spot in NYC. Have been ordering pizza from this spot for about 2 year
Typical take out/dine in pizza spot in NYC. Have been ordering pizza from this spot for about 2 years and it never disappoints. Lots of different pizza choices & awesome canned/draft beer selections. Only knock are the garlic knots- they need a little crunch on the exterior. Personal favorites: Vodka & Pepperoni ... read more
Casey S. via yelp.com - Aug 9, 2021
This place is really good. Crispy crust, nice sidewalk cafe setup and staff was friendly. They have these little pepperoni pinwheels that were sooo good and their garlic knots were delicious. Tried the mushroom slice and it was very very tasty. When I'm back on the UWS, I'll definitely stop here again.
Carol Alexander via google.com - Aug 6, 2021
This place is really good. Crispy crust, nice sidewalk cafe setup and staff was friendly. They have
This place is really good. Crispy crust, nice sidewalk cafe setup and staff was friendly. They have these little pepperoni pinwheels that were sooo good and their garlic knots were delicious. Tried the mushroom slice and it was very very tasty. When I'm back on the UWS, I'll definitely stop here again.
Carol M. via yelp.com - Jul 31, 2021
This is my go to. The mushroom pizza is super garlicky and the sausage and pepperoni is a default choice. Never have i been disappointed by this place ... read more
Peter Dahdouh via google.com - Jul 30, 2021
Great pizza. Period. Stop reading this and just eat it.
Evan Rothstein via google.com - Jul 30, 2021
Best GF pizza!!! I got the vodka pizza and it was incredible. The staff is super friendly and it's s
Best GF pizza!!! I got the vodka pizza and it was incredible. The staff is super friendly and it's super clean inside. This is definitely my favorite pizza place on the UWS ... read more
Sophie O. via yelp.com - Jul 26, 2021
Best value-priced slices in UWS in my opinion. A go-to neighborhood spot for anyone craving a "New York slice" ... read more
Arun Narasimhan via google.com - Jul 20, 2021
We arrived here on a Saturday night, and it wasn't too crowded, so we seated straight away. We all got pizza, which was delicious. A medium fed about three of us, giving us each two large portions.
Eunice Palmer via google.com - Jul 20, 2021
This is a place I love and the food is solid. The people are very very lovely... a perfect spot for pizza. If you're looking for pizzas that aren't typical, this is the place.
Lorelei Webb via google.com - Jul 20, 2021
Got to try the spicy pep or the vodka slice!
Ross Van Deventer via google.com - Jul 20, 2021
I’m so happy to see this place survived Covid. We stopped in on Saturday for the square pepperoni pizza and just as we remembered from 2019, it was super delicious. We also had the white pizza square and a pizza roll (which had tons of meat). Can’t wait to return for more!
Quiendra Brown via google.com - Jul 20, 2021
The best pizza in the neighborhood ... read more
Manuel Hernandez via google.com - Jul 20, 2021
Perfect crust, perfect pie. Best slice I had in NYC.
Jeff Curl via google.com - Jul 20, 2021
Fantastic pizza just a few blocks from AMNH!!!!!
Nico Kwan via google.com - Jul 20, 2021
I love pizza and been living here in NYC for nearly 20 years. This place is legit. Doesn't have much
I love pizza and been living here in NYC for nearly 20 years. This place is legit. Doesn't have much of a history, but theyve proven to cook up some excellent ny style pizza. Sauce is great. Crust near perfect. Sicilian slices also very good - and I'd say on par with Mama Two's. Service can use an upgrade as the workers there always ... read more
Ww H. via yelp.com - Jul 13, 2021
Caveat off the bat: I haven't had any other pizza here other than the plain cheese. However, I've ha
Caveat off the bat: I haven't had any other pizza here other than the plain cheese. However, I've had the cheese pizza multiple times and can say with confidence that their pizza is among the best this city has to offer. Exactly as cheesy, oily and doughy as it should be. So simple, yet so good.
Ariel O. via yelp.com - Jul 5, 2021
Let’s start with the pepperoni slice. Amazing!!!!!! Ok let’s keep it right there. All the pizza is sensational. The other rolls and items are on par with the pizza. This is a must visit !!!!!
Adam Kaminer via google.com - Jun 20, 2021
Beautiful n.y. pizza.
Jarda Jírů via google.com - Jun 20, 2021
Love there pizza good stuff ... read more
Dana Torres via google.com - Jun 20, 2021
The crust was firm and crunchy. The sauce and cheese were of good quality. The spicy pepperoni was well seasoned and flavorful. This pie may be more akin to a Detroit style but I can proudly state that it's "Made in New York." ... read more
Leonardo Torres via google.com - Jun 20, 2021
My personal "Best Pizza in NYC" for the "Spicy Pepperoni"! And I'm old school Brooklyn!
Greg Dugan via google.com - Jun 20, 2021
Ordered Pepperoni/Sausage and Mushroom slices. The pizza was delicious, the crust was thin and crispy, toppings were good, right amount of sauce, and not dripping with oil (you know, when you fold and oil starts dripping out of the back.) I would definitely get it again, I want to try their square slices.
Albert Li via google.com - Jun 20, 2021
The pizza is really really good has a great crispy crust download the one bite app it will show you the ratings of all the pizzerias in the area on a scale from 1 to 10 ... read more
Biagio Gulino via google.com - Jun 20, 2021
It looked interesting and I went in and knew this was real New York pizza immediately. Ate a peppero
It looked interesting and I went in and knew this was real New York pizza immediately. Ate a pepperoni slice and a sausage slice.
tyagi via tripadvisor.ca - Jun 17, 2021
the best pizza in the upper west side. i have no other comment for it. the cheese pie is amazing. bi
the best pizza in the upper west side. i have no other comment for it. the cheese pie is amazing. big cheesy slices with the perfect amount of sauce to go with each bite. the grandma slices are great. esp the ones with pepperoni , crispy cups of grease with a good crunch on the crust. knots are solid, as are the specialty slides.
Shaila S. via yelp.com - Jun 16, 2021
Made in NY pizza is sensational. Trust me you want you want to get there now before the lines begin
Made in NY pizza is sensational. Trust me you want you want to get there now before the lines begin to grow and grow. They will be soon so popular that the wait in line will be worth it. Pepperoni slice is incredible. I promise you that you won't regret a single bite.
Adam K. via yelp.com - May 29, 2021
While many places in this neighborhood close by 10pm, Made In New York Pizza is open until 11pm and
While many places in this neighborhood close by 10pm, Made In New York Pizza is open until 11pm and is a great option for a slice of pizza. We ordered the Spicy Pepperoni square ($4.50+) and a slice of the Plain Cheese ($3+). It was a nice night out, so we sat at one of their outdoor tables to eat. The sidewalk is wide, so there's pl ... read more
Sawako Y. via yelp.com - May 28, 2021
Really good pizza, make sure to try the pepperoni square, it's so good. Fast and friendly service, a
Really good pizza, make sure to try the pepperoni square, it's so good. Fast and friendly service, always clean.
Darrin L. via yelp.com - May 21, 2021
this pizza is so good and the costumer service it excellent too ... read more
bella rodriguez via google.com - May 20, 2021
Highly DELICIOUS! This restaurant's pizza and pasta are my favorites because they are tasty and filling. Also, the staff here were very attentive and they were able to quickly respond to all of my requests. Indeed, a wonderful location for pizza and pasta connoisseurs! This is a place that I strongly suggest to all!
Izzy Warner via google.com - May 20, 2021
Always good, the pepperoni square slice is the best. 👍🏽 ... read more
Brian Mayers via google.com - May 20, 2021
The pizza pub in this area is a must-visit! The pizza that they serve is mouthwatering. It was so delicious and satisfying. The thin crust pizza in this place is so delicious. The place has a great ambiance. It was so cozy and clean. The staff was so accommodating and friendly as well. I will definitely visit this pizza pub again.
Hajrah Holloway via google.com - May 20, 2021
I liked his communicative skills. It was great. Thanks! Great service!
Alexie Figueroa via google.com - May 20, 2021
My favorite pizza spot in the upper west side! Their pizza is appears flavorful and cooked to perfec
My favorite pizza spot in the upper west side! Their pizza is appears flavorful and cooked to perfection!
Leigh B. via yelp.com - May 15, 2021
Visiting from CA, really good pizza, thin crust. Sold by the slice and they are HUGE! $8 glasses of
Visiting from CA, really good pizza, thin crust. Sold by the slice and they are HUGE! $8 glasses of wine. A fun people watching spot. Garlic knots looked amazing. I'll be back!
Sharon F. via yelp.com - May 8, 2021
La mejor pizza vodka pizza spicy pepperonis on muy buenas con un vaso de cervezaPizza by the Slice
La mejor pizza vodka pizza spicy pepperonis on muy buenas con un vaso de cervezaPizza by the Slice ... read more
Agustin P. via yelp.com - Apr 21, 2021
Best pizza I've found on the UWS.
Nicholas Pabon via google.com - Apr 20, 2021
Such good pizza! The white pizza is a must try. The garlic knots were super yummy too!
Courtney Clem via google.com - Apr 20, 2021
really good pizza. i’m not sure if their ingredients are clean, probably not, but i’ll order again when i want “junk food/bad for you” pizza. the one thing that threw me off was they used red peppers as a topping instead of green. flavors would be so much better with green peppers.
Nestle MoNai via google.com - Apr 20, 2021
Oh my God, Made In New York Pizza was certainly phenomenal. Sooooo good and very well priced. The me
Oh my God, Made In New York Pizza was certainly phenomenal. Sooooo good and very well priced. The menu is really good, lots of excellent choices, I had to go with White Pizza Pie with Ricotta, and it was amazing. The crew was very courteous and service is terrific. Made In New York Pizza is hands down the best of the best in this are ... read more
Cora T. via yelp.com - Apr 10, 2021
This is crazy good! The crust is so crunchy but not oily. You can't have just one slice. On my cheat
This is crazy good! The crust is so crunchy but not oily. You can't have just one slice. On my cheat days, this is my comfort food. I love their pizza!
Rosalea M. via yelp.com - Apr 9, 2021
Made In New York Pizza is consistently good. This was the first place pizza place I ordered from whe
Made In New York Pizza is consistently good. This was the first place pizza place I ordered from when I first moved to New York so it has a special place in my heart. I enjoy everything from the pizza to the garlic knots to the wonderful customer service. The crust is nice and crispy, especially when you order by the slice. Pizza is ... read more
Ann P. via yelp.com - Mar 22, 2021
I had a grandma slice and a Buffalo chicken slice. The grandma slice is very thin and crispy and was
I had a grandma slice and a Buffalo chicken slice. The grandma slice is very thin and crispy and was really delicious. The Buffalo chicken slice was meh. Not much flavor and too doughy. My friend ordered a slice of pepperoni and she really liked it.
Dave G. via yelp.com - Mar 19, 2021
Best pizza in the UWS, hands down. We order from here every week and the quality is consistently exc
Best pizza in the UWS, hands down. We order from here every week and the quality is consistently excellent. Everyone we've recommended this place to has adopted it as their go-to pizza joint. (If you're out of their standard delivery range, they're available citywide on Uber Eats & Door Dash). We love their squares, but the regular c ... read more
Skylar A. via yelp.com - Mar 15, 2021
I'm pretty picky about my pizza. And it takes a lot for me to give a pizza place a five star review.
I'm pretty picky about my pizza. And it takes a lot for me to give a pizza place a five star review. This may actually be the first. I actually stumbled upon it accidentally when I stopped by to visit my husband at his work which is nearby. OMG. So good. So good in fact that I went completely out of my way and in the opposite directi ... read more
J. Lawrence N. via yelp.com - Mar 10, 2021
The sauce, cheese and toppings are great, but the best part, for me, about their pizza is the crust.
The sauce, cheese and toppings are great, but the best part, for me, about their pizza is the crust. It's just the right thickness, very tasty too. The last time we were here we had the white spinach pie and it was great as usual. The staff was friendly and kept safety protocols. One of my favorite pizzerias in the UWS.
Michael M. via yelp.com - Feb 21, 2021
Best grandma's pie on the UWS. I order it way more often than I should. Always hot/fresh when delive
Best grandma's pie on the UWS. I order it way more often than I should. Always hot/fresh when delivered to me 8 blocks away. And usually really quick.
Megan F. via yelp.com - Feb 21, 2021
delicious classic new york pizza - sauce was not too sweet and not overly cheesy - delicious and dep
delicious classic new york pizza - sauce was not too sweet and not overly cheesy - delicious and dependable ... read more
Emma H. via yelp.com - Jan 9, 2021
Made In New York is one of our neighborhood go-to's when we're feeling lazy on a weeknight and in th
Made In New York is one of our neighborhood go-to's when we're feeling lazy on a weeknight and in the mood for something that's the ideal balance of good, quick, and cheap. The highlight of the menu is definitely the spicy pepperoni pizza, which is comparable enough to the O.G. at Prince Street Pizza to be worth avoiding the subway r ... read more
Amol U. via yelp.com - Jan 5, 2021
Really delicious pizza and a staple to our takeout on the UWS. We ordered a margarita pizza and adde
Really delicious pizza and a staple to our takeout on the UWS. We ordered a margarita pizza and added sausage + got an order of pepperoni rolls. The pizza was excellent and the crust was perfect (not burned or charred at all). The pepperoni rolls were a little on the cold side by the time they were delivered, but were delicious nonet ... read more
Amanda U. via yelp.com - Jan 2, 2021
Craving a "Prince Street" square slice but don't wanna shlep downtown? Garlic knots ? Sure, the name
Craving a "Prince Street" square slice but don't wanna shlep downtown? Garlic knots ? Sure, the name is corny AF, but this joint is solid, Gyna. Solid-I say. They are heavy handed with the sauce, though. I'm ok with that, but if you're a BB who is not a fan, you're welcome for the warning. Cheese slice: 4 Garlic knots: 4.6 Sicilian p ... read more
Your Mom's Y. via yelp.com - Dec 12, 2020
Want To Tell Us About Your Experience?
GoogleMyBusinessFoursquareFacebookYelpZomatoTwitterTrip AdvisorYouTubeGrouponInstagramOpen TablePinterestZagatFlickrLinkedInTumblrTheKnotWeddingWire